Why Do Dogs Have Separation Anxiety? 3 Science-Backed Causes Explained
- beverly538
- Oct 23
- 10 min read
In This Article:
The Three Lenses for Understanding Separation Anxiety
Picture this: A 10-year-old German Shepherd, newly adopted, tears through window blinds within sixty seconds of her people stepping outside. Ella's new guardians were heartbroken. Had they made a terrible mistake adopting a senior dog? Was she too old, too set in her ways, too damaged to ever feel safe being alone?
Here's what they didn't know yet: Separation anxiety in dogs isn't a life sentence. Understanding why dogs have separation anxiety—and why some dogs struggle while others don't—requires looking through multiple lenses. And once we understand these different perspectives, we can help dogs like Ella learn that being alone is safe, manageable, and nothing to fear.
Today, Ella's guardians run errands, go to concerts, even take vacations knowing their dog will be just fine. Let me show you how we got there, and why your dog can get there too.
TL;DR - Key Takeaways:
Separation anxiety emerges from genetics, brain chemistry, AND learning experiences
Every dog's anxiety profile is unique and needs an individualized approach
Dogs of any age can learn to be calm alone with the right support
Understanding all three factors is key to effective treatment
The Three Lenses for Understanding Separation Anxiety
When I work with dogs experiencing separation anxiety, I've learned that it's never just one thing. Every dog I meet shows me that separation anxiety emerges from a complex interplay of factors. Think of these not as separate causes, but as different lenses through which we can understand what's happening for each individual dog.
Lens 1: Genetics and Breeding- Why Some Dogs Are More Prone to Separation Anxiety
Dogs are highly social animals that have been selectively bred over thousands of years specifically to bond closely with humans. Unlike their wild counterparts, domestic dogs have undergone unique evolutionary pressures that shaped them into companions rather than independent survivors. This selective breeding for human-directed socialization means attachment behaviors are deeply embedded in dogs—but how secure those attachments feel varies significantly between individuals.
Some dogs may have genetic predispositions based on what they were bred for. Dogs bred for independent work (like livestock guardians or hounds) often show more self-reliance, while breeds developed for constant human companionship (like toy breeds or lap dogs) may need more support in building confidence during alone time. This is about selective breeding for specific traits, not about dominance or pack hierarchies.
Take Cosmo, a husky mix I worked with. His breed background includes dogs bred for endurance work and living closely with teams of other dogs and humans. When Cosmo's people tried to have him sleep in another room at night, he kept them up with constant vocalizations. His high-energy breed characteristics meant he needed the right kind and amount of enrichment activities to help him settle. Looking through this genetic lens helped us understand that Cosmo wasn't being stubborn or manipulative—his breeding simply made him more oriented toward constant proximity with his social group.
Early socialization experiences are also crucial. Puppies that experience gradual, positive exposures to being alone during critical developmental periods (roughly 3-14 weeks) learn that separation is normal and temporary—they develop a secure attachment where they trust their person will return. Those who never learn this—perhaps due to constant human presence or being rehomed multiple times—may struggle with the uncertainty of separation. The goal is always to strengthen the security of the bond, not to weaken it, so the dog feels confident that their guardian will always come back.
Ella came to her new home at 10 years old. We don't know much about her early puppyhood, but we do know she'd experienced at least one major life transition—being rehomed as a senior. German Shepherds are known for forming strong bonds with their people, and Ella needed to learn that these new people were trustworthy and would always return.
Key research supporting this perspective:
Zapata, I., Serpell, J. A., & Alvarez, C. E. (2016). Genetic mapping of canine fear and aggression. BMC Genomics, 17(1), 572.
Salonen, M., et al. (2020). Prevalence, comorbidity, and breed differences in canine anxiety in 13,700 Finnish pet dogs. Scientific Reports, 10(1), 2962.
Storengen, L. M., et al. (2014). A descriptive study of 215 dogs diagnosed with separation anxiety. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 159, 82-89.
Pirrone, F., et al. (2021). Review of epidemiological, pathological, genetic, and epigenetic factors that may contribute to the development of separation anxiety in dogs. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 259(10), 1122-1135.
Lens 2: Brain Chemistry- How Cortisol & Serotonin Affect Dog Anxiety
A dog's brain has a built-in stress response system. When something stressful happens—like being left alone—the brain releases cortisol, a hormone that signals the body to respond to a threat. In dogs who handle being alone well, this stress response activates briefly and then settles down naturally. But in dogs with separation anxiety, their stress response system can become dysregulated, essentially getting stuck in a high-alert state that doesn't calm down easily.
Every dog's brain chemistry is slightly different, similar to how some people are naturally more anxious while others are naturally more relaxed. Dogs have varying baseline levels of neurotransmitters that affect mood and stress regulation. Some dogs might have lower levels of serotonin (which helps regulate mood and promote calmness), or their brains might process oxytocin (the bonding hormone) differently. Additionally, if a dog experienced trauma or chronic stress, especially during their early development, it can actually reshape their neural pathways, making their brain more reactive to perceived threats—including the experience of being left alone.
Some dogs also have temperaments that make them more prone to worry. They're naturally more vigilant, less adaptable to change, and more reactive to uncertainty. This isn't a character flaw or something they can simply control; it's neurobiological variation.
Just as some people have a lower threshold for anxiety, some dogs are predisposed to struggle more with situations that require self-soothing and distress tolerance. Understanding these brain-based differences helps explain why separation anxiety isn't about a dog being "badly behaved"—it's a genuine emotional and physiological response.
Remember Ella tearing through those blinds within one minute? That immediate, intense panic response shows us her stress system wasn't just activated—it was completely overwhelmed. Her brain perceived the departure as a genuine emergency. This wasn't destructive behavior out of boredom or spite; it was a physiological panic response she couldn't control.
Notice how these lenses overlap: Ella's breed background (Lens 1) may have made her more prone to strong bonding, which combined with her senior adoption experience, likely influenced how her brain's stress system (Lens 2) responded to being alone in a new environment.
Key research supporting this perspective:
Buttner, A. P., et al. (2023). Early life adversity in dogs produces altered physiological and behavioral responses during a social stress-buffering paradigm. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 119(3), 473-492.
Hennessy, M. B., Willen, R. M., & Schiml, P. A. (2020). Psychological stress, its reduction, and long-term consequences: What studies with laboratory animals might teach us about life in the dog shelter. Animals, 10(11), 2061.
Alberghina, D., et al. (2022). The variation of serotonin values in dogs in different environmental conditions. Animals, 12(20), 2842.
Ding, L., et al. (2021). Association between temperament related traits and single nucleotide polymorphisms in the serotonin and oxytocin systems in Merino sheep. Genes, Brain and Behavior, 20(2), e12714.
Lens 3: Learning History- What Your Dog’s Environment Teaches About Being Alone
A dog's daily experiences and what they've learned about separations profoundly shape their response. Dogs are exceptional at pattern recognition and association. If departures have consistently been paired with negative experiences (long durations alone without preparation, traumatic events, or highly stressful situations), dogs learn that separation predicts something bad. However, because dogs continue learning throughout their entire lives, we can help them form new, positive associations with being alone.
The home environment matters significantly. Dogs need appropriate outlets for their energy and mental engagement, but balance is key—over-stimulation or excessive activity can actually make it harder for a dog to settle and relax. A predictable routine and a calm home environment help dogs feel secure and better able to handle alone time.
This is where Cosmo's story really shines. Once we increased his enrichment activities to match his husky energy levels and combined that with a careful, gradual introduction to sleeping in another room, he figured out how to relax when his people were elsewhere. He needed to learn that nighttime separation was safe, and he needed appropriate outlets for his energy so his brain could actually settle.
Minnie and Monty, a bonded pair of mixed-breed dogs, show us another aspect of this learning lens. Before their alone time training, they were tearing up the sofa together and creating chaos at home. They needed more practice being left alone, both in and out of their crates. A slow re-introduction to alone time meant they could learn how to keep calm and not panic when their humans were gone. Notice the word "learn"—that's what this lens is all about. These skills can be taught.
Human behavior also plays a crucial role. Most of us aren't taught how our daily routines affect our dogs' learning about separation. Calm, brief departures and arrivals help dogs see these moments as unremarkable. Regular short practice sessions of alone time—even when we're home—build confidence gradually. These aren't intuitive practices, but once guardians understand how dogs learn, adjusting these patterns becomes straightforward.
Learning to be alone calmly is a skill that some dogs pick up easily and others find more challenging, depending on their history and temperament. Dogs and puppies whose histories of being left alone only include frightening or overwhelming experiences will understandably struggle more. But the important thing is that with patience, proper training techniques, and the right environmental setup, we can help any dog learn that being alone is safe and manageable. By creating the right conditions—gradual exposure, positive associations, and building confidence—we can teach these important lessons at any stage of a dog's life.
For Ella, this meant first proving to her that her people always came back. Every single time. Once she learned that fundamental lesson—that departures predict returns—we added enrichment for when she was alone to help her settle even more. The combination of a secure foundation ("they always come back") plus positive activities while alone transformed her experience.
Ready for personalized help with your dog's separation anxiety?
Key research supporting this perspective:
Sargisson, R. J. (2014). Canine separation anxiety: Strategies for treatment and management. Veterinary Medicine: Research and Reports, 5, 143-151.
Mundell, P., et al. (2020). An automated behavior-shaping intervention reduces signs of separation anxiety–related distress in a mixed-breed dog. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 37, 1-6.
Burton, B. (2021). Literature review: Behavior modification for canine separation anxiety. IAABC Foundation Journal, 18.
Ogata, N. (2016). Separation anxiety in dogs: What progress has been made in our understanding of the most common behavioral problems in dogs? Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 16, 28-35.
Why Multiple Lenses Matter
Here's what I want you to understand: The dogs I work with remind me daily that separation anxiety isn't caused by just one thing. It's always a combination of who they are (genetics and breed characteristics), how their brain processes stress (neuroscience and temperament), and what they've learned (environment and experience).
Ella's story perfectly illustrates this. Her German Shepherd genetics gave her a strong bonding tendency (Lens 1). Her senior adoption and unknown history likely shaped her stress response system (Lens 2). And her previous experiences taught her that being alone was terrifying—until we helped her learn something new (Lens 3).
The same is true for Cosmo, whose husky genetics, energy levels, brain chemistry, and learning history all played a role. And for Minnie and Monty, whose bonded relationship added yet another layer to their individual experiences of separation.
This complexity isn't overwhelming—it's actually empowering. Because when we understand that separation anxiety emerges from multiple factors, we can address it from multiple angles. We're not looking for one magic solution; we're creating an individualized approach that considers the whole dog.
Can Separation Anxiety in Dogs Be Cured? - There Is Always Hope
Remember Ella, tearing through those blinds within a minute of being left alone? Today, her guardians live full lives. They run errands without worry. They go to work knowing Ella is calm at home. They even take vacations, confident their 10-year-old dog—once so panicked she destroyed window coverings in seconds—will be absolutely fine.
Cosmo's people get full nights of sleep now, and Cosmo peacefully rests in his own space. Minnie and Monty's sofa is intact, and their humans can leave for work without coming home to chaos.
These dogs aren't special cases. They're proof of what I see every day in my work: Separation anxiety can be managed and helped at any age. Whether your dog is a puppy still learning about the world, an adult who never learned to be alone, or a senior adjusting to a new home, it's never too late.
And here's the other crucial truth: Separation anxiety looks different and needs an individualized approach. What worked for Ella (proving departures predict returns, then adding enrichment) looked different from what worked for Cosmo (enrichment first, then gradual nighttime separation) and different still from Minnie and Monty's approach (practicing both crated and uncrated alone time in small increments).
Your dog's separation anxiety is unique because your dog is unique. Their genetics, their brain chemistry, their learning history—all of these factors combine to create their individual experience. And that means there's a path forward designed specifically for them.
Understanding separation anxiety through these multiple lenses—evolutionary, neurological, and environmental—isn't just intellectually interesting. It's the foundation for real, lasting change. It helps us see our dogs with compassion, recognize that their distress is genuine, and know exactly how to help them build the skills and confidence they need.
Frequently Asked Questions About Dog Separation Anxiety
Q: At what age do dogs develop separation anxiety? A: Dogs can develop separation anxiety at any age, from puppyhood through senior years. Ella was 10 years old when adopted and successfully learned to be calm alone.
Q: Can separation anxiety in older dogs be cured? A: Yes! With the right approach considering genetics, brain chemistry, and learning history, dogs of any age can learn to feel safe being alone.
Q: Is separation anxiety genetic in dogs? A: Genetics play a role - some breeds bred for close human companionship may be more prone. However, brain chemistry and learning experiences are equally important factors.
Q: How long does it take to treat separation anxiety in dogs? A: Every dog is different. With individualized training, some dogs show improvement in weeks, while others need several months. Progress depends on severity and the dog's unique profile.
Your dog can learn to be alone. At any age. With the right approach. I've seen it happen again and again.
The blinds can be repaired. The sofa can be replaced. But the bond you build with your dog as you help them through their fear? That's irreplaceable. And it starts with understanding.
Ready to Help Your Dog Feel Safe Alone?
Whether your dog is tearing through blinds like Ella, keeping you up at night like Cosmo, or destroying furniture like Minnie and Monty - there's hope.
Comments